R12 Parallel Terminal-State Quotient Preregistration

Status

Implemented and locally qualified on 2026-08-01. The preregistered H100 arm and a matched V100 numerical replication are complete and negative.

Causal diagnosis

The strongest learned COMMAND mechanism is a one-pass parallel schedule compiler. It can reach nonzero fully autonomous WORLD and COMMAND strict pairs, but the effect is initialization- and population-sensitive. Better exact schedule accuracy, grounded pointers, semantic-prefix credit, fieldwise multi-basin averaging, and training on the deployed initial packet do not make the result stable. The common defect is supervision of one arbitrary ordered transaction serialization even though many schedules denote the same semantic terminal state.

Treatment

ParallelTerminalStateCompiler predicts the query-independent terminal typed state directly from:

1. the initial typed state produced before COMMAND, and
2. frozen Shohin residuals for the candidate-visible COMMAND bytes.

It emits active slots, one-or-none root, value code, type, sparse typed relations, committed, and halted. Hard inference enforces all typed packet constraints and the relation edge cap. The complete 64-step learned policy is removed from deployment. The model receives no QUERY bytes, answer token, target packet, oracle program, best-of-K scorer, verifier, or host solver.

The production geometry is width 512, four joint slot layers, eight attention heads, and relation rank 64. It adds 18,520,349 parameters. Replacing the dead 29,757,217-parameter recurrent reactor keeps the complete system below 200M.

Objective

The only training target is the exact terminal packet equivalence class. Binary fields use class-balanced Brier loss; value and type use categorical Brier loss on target-active slots. Sparse relation loss uses the assessor mask. The primary arm trains from Shohin's hard detached autonomous WORLD packet, which matches deployment. An oracle-initial arm is an admissible matched diagnostic, not a promoted result.

First gate

• architecture seed: 31
• data seed: 11
• stream position: 0
• updates: 500
• learning rate: 3e-4
• gradient clip: 1.0
• evaluation: 32 batches / 512 rows
• inference: one hard terminal state, no candidate selection

The protected Shohin checkpoint, algebraic query compiler/reader, release, source-deleted evaluator, and public gate definitions remain unchanged.

Promotion rule

Loss, soft packet loss, per-field terminal accuracy, complete packet accuracy, factual top-1, and oracle-program arms are diagnostics only. The mechanism is extended only if the fully autonomous arm improves both strict WORLD and strict COMMAND, or produces a clearly positive margin-1 precursor without a large factual collapse. A claim requires simultaneous strict WORLD and COMMAND improvement on three distinct held-out data orderings and more than one architecture seed.

Rejection rule

Reject direct terminal-state quotient transport as currently formulated if:

• it learns terminal labels but strict WORLD and COMMAND remain zero;
• only one causal factor improves;
• the result depends on oracle initial state;
• the result disappears on fresh data orderings or a second architecture seed;
• or it violates the typed hard-state or 200M parameter contracts.

Interpretation boundary

A positive result would show that Shohin can learn a query-independent semantic state transition without committing to an arbitrary operation serialization. It would not by itself prove unrestricted general reasoning beyond the frozen factorial qualification families.

Result

The H100 arm completed 500 updates with final loss 0.0646163. It reached 70.31% fully autonomous factual top-1, 99.32% active, 100% root and terminal status, 99.61% relation-coordinate accuracy, 91.03% type, and 52.88% value. Despite that broad field fit, exact terminal packets remained 0/512 and the unchanged fully autonomous source-deleted gate remained WORLD 0%, COMMAND 0%, and margin-1 0% for both. WORLD DID was exactly zero and COMMAND DID was numerical zero (-1.63e-7). Report SHA-256 is e36f95c042987423974dba65ff3c31adbfca4e8ef3ef224c5c10af1ae43ed5b1.

The same arm independently completed on a V100 with final loss 0.0734916, 67.19% factual top-1, and again zero WORLD/COMMAND strict and margin-1 gates. Report SHA-256 is 5a8fab285b7007d63320f7590e4cf074b212277086e2318c964a983e02fedea0. This rejects hardware noise and closes unweighted fieldwise terminal-state transport. It learns the common terminal manifold while averaging away the rare coordinates that distinguish the complete 2x2 interventions.

Disposition: reject_fieldwise_terminal_quotient_retain_architecture_for_explicit_rectangle_delta_credit.