R12 Referential Identity Packet Probe Result
Decision: admit the lexical set-valued packet as the only bounded RGDE v1.1 repair. This is a no-fit carrier result, not an executor or reasoning result.
Frozen run
- Job
693117completed0:0on H100evc29in 14 seconds. - It used the frozen raw-300k base, qualified ordinary compiler, and 2,048-row public compositional development split.
- It performed no optimizer update, state transition, answer prediction, confirmation access, retry, or arm selection.
- Result SHA-256:
dcc16fa3101e403a5cd2452171511fe9f4497c5c879ca1fa65da0e31ba615f60. - Log SHA-256:
9eefc04dfedfe65b9e4d221c85a4ae041bcede71dc8654041c293ffef3cccd55.
Result
The probe asks whether each operation entity is nearest to the matching one of the three initial entities, using only the gathered vectors.
| Carrier | Correct | Accuracy |
|---|---|---|
| contextual state + pointer softmax (RGDE v1) | 1,312/4,096 | 32.031% |
| frozen token embedding + pointer softmax | 2,966/4,096 | 72.412% |
| frozen token embedding + normalized sigmoid role span | 4,090/4,096 | 99.854% |
| frozen token embedding + gold span | 4,096/4,096 | 100.000% |
The admitted carrier scores 99.805% on canonical, binding-twin, and order-twin surfaces and 100% on paraphrase. The v1 compiler had already selected a token inside the correct span 99.982% of the time, but softmax chose the same single subtoken across the two entity occurrences only 59.326% of the time. The new carrier interprets a role as a set: sigmoid each role logit, mask invalid tokens, normalize over the set, and average the frozen vocabulary embeddings.
Interpretation
The failed RGDE v1 did not establish that source deletion destroys entity identity. It established that a categorical one-token gather is the wrong interface for multi-token referents. A zero-parameter set-valued lexical channel nearly saturates the no-fit identity test while leaving operation semantics in the contextual channel.
This authorizes one frozen v1.1 executor experiment. It does not authorize old confirmation access, broader fitting, a natural-language claim, or a novelty claim.